CO129-125 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [10-11] — Page 216

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

That though some parts of Mr. G. W. H. Hay's opinion may fairly be open to doubt, it does not seem necessary to repeat the discussion after the Law Officers' report of the 15th January 1867, to discuss any further the question of the extent of English jurisdiction in waters adjacent to the Colony of Hong Kong.

There remains, however, the question as to Kowloon, Lamma Island, and other adjacent islands; and it is desired to state that though there is a repetition of Sir R. Alcock's opinion that any negotiation upon the subject would be fruitless with the Chinese Government, Sir R. Alcock feels that from his position on the subject, the matter should be put up for the present, therefore, any attempt at negotiation is hopeless.

But considering the vicinity of that island to Hong Kong, and its comparative size, which renders it an easy asylum for lawless characters, it is very desirable that some step should be taken to give the Government control over the Supreme Court.

Edit History

2026-05-19 22:47:28 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
That though some parts of Mr. G. W. H. Hay's opinion may fairly be open to doubt, it does not seem necessary to repeat the discussion after the Law Officers' report of the 15th January 1867, to discuss any further the question of the extent of English jurisdiction in waters adjacent to the Colony of Hong Kong. There remains, however, the question as to Kowloon, Lamma Island, and other adjacent islands; and it is desired to state that though there is a repetition of Sir R. Alcock's opinion that any negotiation upon the subject would be fruitless with the Chinese Government, Sir R. Alcock feels that from his position on the subject, the matter should be put up for the present, therefore, any attempt at negotiation is hopeless. But considering the vicinity of that island to Hong Kong, and its comparative size, which renders it an easy asylum for lawless characters, it is very desirable that some step should be taken to give the Government control over the Supreme Court.
Baseline (Original)
that though some parts pir 2 Homily's opinion may fairly pen to doubt, it don wt seem necessay, repat of after the the Law Officers I K the 15 January 1867, discuss any further ther question of the extent of Anlish jurisdiction in water adjacent with Colony of the There remains, the question as Kory. however, to the diction arr Lamma juris Jam Island; and desired to state that though Ith repeti герей blearn that Für R Alcock in quinion that any neptiation upon 215 fruit with the thin cre и fovernment wows in hopeles, Wet Hy feel that Sir R A the Tabject the mater Hay Alcock from his portion the bed pidge Hel for the present, therefore, at negotiation any attempt at mouth porn up. But considering the vicently of that island to Hong Kong, & its comparative siger, which Lenders it an lary and Sears asylum for therever & pensan he of lawless character, HC Which it very desirable that some step should I taken to give Eovernment to the Supreme fort
2026-05-19 22:47:28 · Baseline
View content

that though some parts pir 2 Homily's opinion may fairly pen to doubt, it don

wt seem necessay,

repat of

after the

the Law Officers I

K

the 15 January 1867, discuss any further ther question of the extent of

Anlish jurisdiction in water adjacent with Colony of the

There remains,

the question

as

Kory.

however,

to the

diction arr

Lamma

juris

Jam

Island; and

desired

to state that though

Ith repeti герей

blearn that

Für R Alcock in

quinion that any neptiation upon

215

fruit with the thin cre

и

fovernment wows in hopeles,

Wet Hy feel that Sir R

A

the Tabject the mater

Hay

Alcock from his portion the bed pidge Hel

for

the present, therefore,

at negotiation

any attempt at mouth porn up.

But considering

the vicently

of that island to Hong Kong,

& its comparative siger, which

Lenders it an

lary

and

Sears

asylum for therever & pensan

he

of lawless character, HC Which

it

very

desirable that

some step should I taken

to give

Eovernment

to the Supreme fort

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.